Personally, I love Both but i slightly prefer the book version of edward because the book version seemed more real for me and he's sorta the type of guy i want in my life (how im gonna find a vampire to marry is the part i ain't quite worked out yet) but who do you prefer?
Well, of course the book version is preferable. Stephenie's very talented at describing in enough detail to make you sigh. But he seems more realistic in the movie, and not to mention Rob Pattinson is very, very, very, very, very, very hot. I like to see his face while thinking of Edward Cullen. So a nice compromise would be that, if they ever do make an anime graphic novel out of the books like Stephenie said, they have Rob's face pasted on there. That would be perfection. :)
I too prefer book Edward,because he is - ideal,and too pity,that person like he don`t exist.Well, i want to say,that Exactly Edward we can not find ever...