The way Edward broke up with Bella

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Jasontheundead! on April 2, 2009 at 10:36pm

But you have to think, that would have made it worse for her.

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by alekhya iyengar on April 4, 2009 at 12:53pm

it would have been unsafe for bella.......well edward was replaced by jacob to help her recover......but still there was a hollow part in her heart.......but if he wouldn't have left at the first place there would be no jacob handling the situation and how would u expect the third book to end??

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by alekhya iyengar on April 4, 2009 at 12:50pm

well....i side with edward....cuz he wanted her to be safe.....it was and infact is his main agenda........so he spoke cruelly but did not expect bella to agree with his decision so easily....he was hoping for her to to be stubborn......he suffered the pain.....

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Farishtha sahadew on April 4, 2009 at 9:08pm

My gosh i cried about ten times throughout new moon, it was too too sad i would've had a heart attack if i were bella, all that perfectness gone, life would definatly have no meaning left.

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Amanda Roe on April 7, 2009 at 1:20pm

Read on.. yes it was very cruel, hated him for a second also. but defo need to read on,

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Bella Marie Swan Cullen on April 7, 2009 at 10:48pm

he did it because he and his family were in danger so he wanted to proctect bella from getting hurt but she found that when she did something stupid she heard his voice and it souneded like he was right there by her and i know it was wrong but he did it out of love and i was wrong that he did that i know it was but now he finally relizes that he can't go with out her and was going to come home and be with bella and take care of her . But Rosalie tells him that she killed her-self wich she never did she did jump off the DAMN clif and goes and saves him ... Rosealie appoliges to him and to bella she hanks her for going and saving her brother

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by XxXx_kitty_kat_xXxX on April 8, 2009 at 10:12pm

i agree with u on that part.....................if that happened to me i dont think i would recover................i do agree thoguh that in will love him forever as he is sstill asweetheart and always will be

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by valeska..haunt of the night on April 12, 2009 at 4:45am

well when i read that part i cry so much cuz i don't know it was like if i were on bella place o god i cry so much that day then i start to be so mad at he!!!!

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by anne fey (Lilith of The Crows) on April 15, 2009 at 10:52pm

i know my heart almost tore out because of the passage in the book i mean really

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Mrs Christina Isabella McPherson on April 24, 2009 at 8:21am

I cried too! I couldn't believe he done that! The way he just left her like that, I would probably be the same. But the way she goes to Italy to save him from the Volturi was just amazing. Can't wait for the new movie and I hope they keep the marriage proposal in it! I cried at that too!

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by XxXxxMYsTeRioUS GuRLXxXx on May 1, 2009 at 2:10am

OMG!!! i reacted the same way i was like how could he be so mean and heartless towards bella,i dont mean to give the story away but in New Moon you actually start thinking Edwards and Bella's relationship might be over,but everybody knows that they belong together.If you dont like Jacob you start to love him because he's being so helpful to Bella, but Jacob can be an asshole. because in eclispe he is all up in bella and edwards kool-aid trying to find out when he's gonna turn her and when their gonna get married. this was a very awesome discussion cluadette

▶ Reply to This

Permalink Reply by Carmela Marie Cullen on May 15, 2009 at 5:20am

in the New Moon Chapter, "The End"... Bella was really hurt but even though Edward left her.. he loved so much he had to leave her coz he thought that it was best for her to have a normal human life without him but without bella... His lifewas... EXCRUCIATING.
Here is the part...

"Okay, let's talk," I said. It sounded braver than it felt.
He took a deep breath.
"Bella, we're leaving."
I took a deep breath, too. This was an acceptable option. I thought I was prepared. But I still had to ask.
"Why now? Another year—"
"Bella, it's time. How much longer could we stay in Forks, after all? Carlisle can barely pass for thirty,
and he's claiming thirty-three now. We'd have to start over soon regardless."
His answer confused me. I thought the point of leaving was to let his family live in peace. Why did we
have to leave if they were going? I stared at him, trying to understand what he meant.
He stared back coldly.
With a roll of nausea, I realized I'd misunderstood.
"When you say we—," I whispered.
"I mean my family and myself." Each word separate and distinct.
I shook my head back and forth mechanically, trying to clear it. He waited without any sign of
impatience. It took a few minutes before I could speak.
"Okay," I said. "I'll come with you."
"You can't, Bella. Where we're going… It's not the right place for you."
"Where you are is the right place for me."
"I'm no good for you, Bella."
"Don't be ridiculous." I wanted to sound angry, but it just sounded like I was begging. "You're the very
best part of my life."
"My world is not for you," he said grimly.
"What happened with Jasper—that was nothing, Edward! Nothing!"
"You're right," he agreed. "It was exactly what was to be expected."
"You promised! In Phoenix, you promised that you would stay—"
"As long as that was best for you," he interrupted to correct me.
"No! This is about my soul, isn't it?" I shouted, furious, the words exploding out of me—somehow it still
sounded like a plea. "Carlisle told me about that, and I don't care, Edward. I don't care! You can have
my soul. I don't want it without you—it's yours already!"
He took a deep breath and stared, unseeingly, at the ground for a long moment. His mouth twisted the
tiniest bit. When he finally looked up, his eyes were different, harder—like the liquid gold had frozen
solid.
"Bella, I don't want you to come with me." He spoke the words slowly and precisely, his cold eyes on
my face, watching as I absorbed what he was really saying.
There was a pause as I repeated the words in my head a few times, sifting through them for their real
intent.
"You… don't… want me?" I tried out the words, confused by the way they sounded, placed in that
order.
"No."
I stared, uncomprehending, into his eyes. He stared back without apology. His eyes were like
topaz—hard and clear and very deep. I felt like I could see into them for miles and miles, yet nowhere in
rheir bottomless depths could I see a contradiction to the word he'd spoken.
"Well, that changes things." I was surprised by how calm and reasonable my voice sounded. It must be
because I was so numb. I couldn't realize what he was telling me. It still didn't make any sense.
He looked away into the trees as he spoke again. "Of course, I'll always love you… in a way. But what
happened the other night made me realize that it's time for a change. Because I'm… tired of pretending
to be something I'm not, Bella. I am not human." He looked back, and the icy planes of his perfect face
were not human. "I've let this go on much too long, and I'm sorry for that."
"Don't." My voice was just a whisper now; awareness was beginning to seep through me, trickling like
acid through my veins. "Don't do this."
He just stared at me, and I could see from his eyes that my words were far too late. He already had.
"You're not good for me, Bella." He turned his earlier words around, and so I had no argument. How
well I knew that I wasn't good enough for him.
I opened my mouth to say something, and then closed it again. He waited patiently, his face wiped clean
of all emotion. I tried again.
"If… that's what you want."
He nodded once.
My whole body went numb. I couldn't feel anything below the neck.
"I would like to ask one favor, though, if that's not too much," he said.
I wonder what he saw on my face, because something flickered across his own face in response. But,
before I could identify it, he'd composed his features into the same serene mask.
"Anything," I vowed, my voice faintly stronger.
As I watched, his frozen eyes melted. The gold became liquid again, molten, burning down into mine with
an intensity that was overwhelming.
"Don't do anything reckless or stupid," he ordered, no longer detached. "Do you understand what I'm
saying?"
I nodded helplessly.
His eyes cooled, the distance returned. "I'm thinking of Charlie, of course. He needs you. Take care of
yourself—for him."
I nodded again. "I will," I whispered.
He seemed to relax just a little.
"And I'll make you a promise in return," he said. "I promise that this will be the last time you'll see me. I
won't come back. I won't put you through anything like this again. You can go on with your life without
any more interference from me. It will be as if I'd never existed."

▶ Reply to This

• First
• Previous
• Next
• Last