Personally, I love Both but i slightly prefer the book version of edward because the book version seemed more real for me and he's sorta the type of guy i want in my life (how im gonna find a vampire to marry is the part i ain't quite worked out yet) but who do you prefer?
Lol I totally know what you know what you mean, *giggle silently* but I wouldn't mind to see Edward played by a gorgeous guy I just don't agree with most girls about Robert, I'm not going to say any thing bad about him though.
I agree i kinda prefer the book because he's like this dream come true but robert plays Edward well and i still fall in live with him lol x and if u find a vampire to marry can u check if he has a brother :)
The book version is better but I can't agree that Robert played Edward well, I mean he had his moments, but he is so ugly in my opinion. I truely can not understand why girls druel over the dude. I would have picked two actors on the top of my head that would have been better fit for the job, but it was a low budget film. I think twilight came out pretty good for a low budget film.
I think that i prefer the book character to the movie character.But rob did a great job of making him come to life.I just felt the book edward more as far as his emotions,and what he was going through.
i like the movie version just because he seemes a bit less controling... i still like edward but after reading the whole series a few extra times im beginig to wonder if jacob was the better match... i think the last book was a little rushed and flakey in my opinion to end the seiries.
Oh my gosh I totally agree, but the book character was more realistic than Edward in the movie. I would have like to see more emotion in the movie but it was pretty good any how. Yeah, I totally agree what's up with the last book having more action and details than the first three all together.